← Back to papers

Diagnosis, treatment and prognosis of simple hepatic cyst: Clinical practice guideline

★ ★ ★ ★ ☆

Paper Summary

Paperzilla title
A South Korean Guideline for Simple Hepatic Cysts: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Prognosis

This clinical practice guideline provides a framework for managing simple hepatic cysts, tailored to the South Korean context. It addresses diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis, adapting international guidelines to suit local realities.

Explain Like I'm Five

Simple hepatic cysts are fluid-filled sacs in the liver. This guideline helps doctors in South Korea diagnose and treat them.

Possible Conflicts of Interest

This guideline was supported by the Korean Association of Hepato-Biliary-Pancreatic Surgery. While no direct financial conflicts are disclosed, the involvement of this professional organization could potentially introduce bias towards surgical interventions.

Identified Limitations

Limited evidence base
The guideline acknowledges a gap in high-level evidence, particularly regarding simple hepatic cysts, relying on expert consensus due to the scarcity of robust data. This reliance on expert opinion might introduce bias and limit the strength of recommendations.
Narrow Scope
The guideline focuses solely on simple hepatic cysts, excluding other hepatic cystic lesions. While this streamlines the content, it restricts the guideline's applicability to a subset of hepatic cystic diseases, potentially leaving clinicians without clear guidance for other related conditions.
Lack of Comparison between treatment modalities
The guideline doesn't offer a clear comparison of the effectiveness and risks associated with different treatment modalities for simple hepatic cysts. This makes it difficult to determine the optimal treatment strategy for individual patients.
Limited generalizability
The guideline is explicitly tailored to the South Korean context, considering local epidemiological and clinical factors. This context-specific approach limits the generalizability of the guideline's recommendations to other populations or healthcare settings.

Rating Explanation

This guideline provides practical guidance for managing simple hepatic cysts, a condition with increasing prevalence. The adaptation of international guidelines to the South Korean context enhances its relevance for domestic clinicians. However, limitations include reliance on expert consensus due to a limited evidence base, a narrow scope focusing only on simple cysts, lack of treatment comparison and limited generalizability beyond the specific context. These constraints prevent a rating of 5.

Good to know

This is the Starter analysis. Paperzilla Pro fact-checks every citation, researches author backgrounds and funding sources, and uses advanced AI reasoning for more thorough insights.

Explore Pro →

Topic Hierarchy

Domain: Health Sciences
Field: Medicine
Subfield: Hepatology

File Information

Original Title: Diagnosis, treatment and prognosis of simple hepatic cyst: Clinical practice guideline
Uploaded: September 09, 2025 at 08:15 PM
Privacy: Public