Paper Summary
Paperzilla title
'Anxiety' and 'Depression' Got More Intense, Not Less: A Surprising Look at How We Talk About Mental Health
Contrary to the hypothesis of concept creep where mental health terms dilute over time, the study found that the language around 'anxiety' and 'depression' became more emotionally intense over the past 50 years. This shift is attributed to the increased clinical framing of these concepts, with words like 'disorder' and 'symptom' becoming more frequently associated with them.
Possible Conflicts of Interest
The authors acknowledge funding from the Australian Research Council Discovery Projects awarded to Nick Haslam (DP170104948 and DP210103984). No other conflicts were disclosed. However, it could be argued that there may be a potential conflict in that some research in this area is funded by pharmaceutical companies that could profit from the expansion of mental health diagnoses, but there's no evidence this applies to this study.
Identified Weaknesses
Generalizability of General Corpus
The generalizability of findings from the general corpus is limited due to the unrepresentative nature of content producers (authors, journalists, bloggers) whose texts make up the corpus.
Corpus Composition Changes
Unrelated historical changes in the composition of corpora (e.g., proportion of clinical psychology articles) could influence severity trends.
The severity index, based on emotional meaning norms, may not fully capture the complexity of harm, which can have moral components beyond affective intensity.
Potential historical shifts in word connotations might complicate interpretation of trends, though a generalized increase in emotional severity is unlikely.
Rating Explanation
The study uses a robust methodology and large datasets, demonstrating clear trends across both academic and general corpora. While the corpora composition and reliance on emotional meaning norms pose some limitations, the replicated findings and exploration of specific collocates strengthen the analysis. The rating is slightly lowered from 5 to 4 to reflect the potential conflict of interest related to pharmaceutical funding in the broader area, though no direct link is apparent to this study.
Good to know
This is our free standard analysis. Paperzilla Pro fact-checks every citation, researches author backgrounds and funding sources, and uses advanced AI reasoning for more thorough insights.
File Information
Original Title:
Have the concepts of 'anxiety' and 'depression' been normalized or pathologized? A corpus study of historical semantic change
Uploaded:
July 14, 2025 at 05:14 PM
© 2025 Paperzilla. All rights reserved.